The sign of a strong horror film is one that can properly shake and unnerve it’s audience without the need for or over reliance on jump scares or over the top gore. Instead, those that use filmmaking techniques, sound, editing, dialogue, cinematography and acting, to create a sense of dread and fear are the ones that stick in the mind long after the film has finished. One of my favourite films from last year was Doctor Sleep, a film that managed to achieve horror without constant jump scares and The Lighthouse manages to do it to an even greater level, taking it almost past the horror genre and into a different mix of genres entirely, which in a way almost helps to make it even more terrifying than if it had remained solely within the horror bracket.
The Lighthouse, directed by Robert Eggers is a film set in the 19th century, centred around two men, played by Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe, who are working together as lighthouse keepers. As time passes and they become stranded, their sanity begins to slip and their relationship starts to dissolve, with the viewer being pulled into the madness as the tension between the two escalates. The plot itself starts from a very basic concept, but the film is really about the dynamic between the two characters, with supernatural and cosmic horror elements coming into play as the film progresses. The film is shot in black and white, with a 1.19:1 aspect ratio, most notably used in the 1920’s and 1930’s, giving the film an old fashioned feel, whilst also adding to the claustrophobic, boxed in feeling that the characters are going through, it’s an incredibly effective and interesting way to shoot the film and really makes it a great cinematic experience.
The use of black and white in the film is not only done for the purpose of making the film look old-fashioned, it also fits thematically, with the lighting being used to get across the concept of secrecy and paranoia within the film, both men seem to be telling their own lies throughout and keeping hold of their own mysteries, adding to the sense of unpredictability, something that is essential for this type of film. Other themes within the film are dominance and subservience, toxic masculinity, sin, positions of power and the rebellion against that power. These themes are put across in some obvious and not so obvious ways and part of the fun of this film is the discussion afterwards around what certain parts of the film meant, there are some really evocative shots within the film, disturbing and beautiful at the same time, with a lot of them almost resembling classical paintings. The film is quite rightly nominated for Best Cinematography at the Oscars, although it could be argued that it could have been put forward for more.
The screenplay, direction and acting are all brilliant here, with the screenplay sticking to this old type of language and committing to it, something that adds to the atmosphere and feel of the film. From reading reports before and after, the shoot for the film sounded really uncomfortable, but the fact that the type of film they wanted to produce was ultimately realised is a huge credit to Robert Eggers and the two main actors for being so invested, at the same time as the shoot sounding uncomfortable, the roles seem like a delight for any actor to play, with so much to delve into with them, as well as the amount of weight they have to carry for the film to come off, with all of the time in the film devoted to them being on screen. Pattinson and Dafoe had to bring absolutely everything to their roles to make the film work and they bring everything and a little bit more too. Pattinson plays a character who comes across as quite vulnerable, with a bubbling temper and feeling of inferiority beneath the surface. Dafoe puts in an absolute powerhouse of a performance, he’s always so involved in every film he stars in. There is one monologue scene here from him that’s absolutely stunning, anyone who has seen the film will know what I’m referring to. He switches between genuine sadness, rage, bitterness and solemn disappointment all within a few seconds and does it to great effect, proving himself once again to be one of the greatest actors around today.
The sound also deserves a mention when talking about what makes this film so impactful. From the very beginning, there’s a really unnerving sound of a bellowing foghorn, which becomes more prominent as the film goes on. There’s also this technique of whenever a character screams, the scream is made to sound incredibly distorted and twisted, giving it this otherworldly feel, perfect for the sections where the film moves into the realm of cosmic horror. The soundscape throughout is incredibly disturbing and pulls you into the world that Eggers has crafted, it has you feeling constantly on edge and uncomfortable, think of films such as The Shining for reference, that film is well remembered for the iconic music within it and I feel as though The Lighthouse cleverly uses sound to the same effect.
My excitement around this type of film being released cannot be understated. Sea shanties are going to dominate my Spotify playlists for the next few days, at least. The response to this film, as well as all of the different aspects that went into making it work, is not just a win for the film itself, but is a huge win for the horror genre overall. I really hope that the success of this film gives confidence to horror writers and directors going forward in having a bit of restraint, as it’s an absolute masterclass in producing a film dripping in gloomy atmosphere, returning horror to doing what it does best, having that effect psychologically and having an impact on the viewer past the point of a few cheap scares. The film asks a lot of deep, existential questions and sometimes these can be a lot scarier than any monster. Apart from the more supernatural elements, the very idea of being stuck in a confined space with another person, slowly going insane is scary enough on it’s own. It is the idea of horror in the mundane, horror in control and the feeling of being controlled, horror in repressed sexuality. Get to see this while you can in the cinema for a different type of experience, it’s a film that needs to be seen and appreciated. Original and creative, The Lighthouse is up there with my favourite films of the year so far.
Overall rating β πππππ/5
